A year after Coachella 2024 concluded, the conversation around that year’s festival has warmed considerably, evolving from initial skepticism to a more reverent appreciation within the fan community. A recent Reddit thread at r/coachella reignited the debate by comparing 2024 with the freshly wrapped 2025 lineup.
Initially, Coachella 2024 faced sharp criticism due to lower-than-expected ticket sales and unusually sparse crowds — empty camping areas and vast polo grounds sparked concern and chatter. Surprisingly, many attendees now highlight this open space as a major asset, allowing for a less cramped experience and a unique festival vibe.
Standout moments like Justice & Gesaffelstein’s electrifying sets, the No Doubt reunion, Tyler the Creator’s headlining performances, and breakout showcases from Chappell & Sabrina became defining memories for attendees. The smaller crowds let fans fully engage with art installations, stages, and surprise moments, creating deep, lasting impressions.
In contrast, Coachella 2025 leaned into party-heavy, high-energy acts such as Charli XCX, Missy Elliott, and Megan Thee Stallion, which delighted many but didn’t overshadow the iconic performances rooted firmly in 2024’s collective memory.
Many voices now call the 2024 festival a quiet but strong contender for their personal favorite Coachella. Its diversity, surprise elements, and overall quality have earned it a cult status — a testament to how a festival year once seen as polarizing can transform into a beloved classic over time.
Source: r/coachella